- I liked NCTEs The Student's Right to Read because it had a lot of good information in it. It is important to have the community involved whether to back you up and to talk offence (even though we don't want this) we want involvement! They need to support us and defend us like the article talks about. This article talks about how censorship poses a threat to education. - "Censorship leaves students with an inadequate and distored picture of the ideals, values, and problems of their culture" . Here even what we as teacher look up to are stating this loud and clear. So how is it that we still have problems with literature that just try to keep students in touch with their realities? Students miss out. They are "denied the freedom to explore ideas and pursue truth wherever and however they wish" IF you didn't get a chance to read this, I really recommend reading it and having it on file in your binders for later date because it really defends us and our choices of books in the classroom. As it talks about establishing committees, getting others involved and even putting together a portfolio of which books are chosen and why they are in order to have documentation for those who disagree which I think is fantastic.
- It was hard to identify completely with Ch.6 of Web because I haven't had the pleasure of reading Huck Finn but I did enjoy the article and learning of its controversy.
Although I really liked the chatting in the head, because communication matters to us so much, yet as a Teacher I fear it. I wouldn't want my students talking in their minds and me not being aware of it. This would be the biggest distraction I could think of for my students. We think that small talk amongst each other near by is a problem we have to deal with, imagine the secretive talk! What could this lead to?! Even the bad things like where would bullying play in? Isn't this what our kids face today, imagine if it went straight to their minds. AH! (shaking my head to get that terrible thought out) But anyway, this book is a good book to view culture and how it influences us so much in our daily lives. I would introduce to this book in a fun way in order to get my students involved despite the language and the ideas of 'going to the moon'. Otherwise, I see teachers having fun with this book, and that's what our kids can appreciate the most!
"It was hard to identify completely with Ch.6 of Web because I haven't had the pleasure of reading Huck Finn but I did enjoy the article and learning of its controversy."
ReplyDeleteLike you, I have never read Huck Finn. I've heard from my peers in high school, though, that you usually love it or hate it. It was hard for me to relate to this chapter as well because it was constantly referring to the text that I did not read. Sometimes I think that authors just assume that all english teachers assign the same novels in EVERY school, so there for it is easy to talk about them. As in the assignment in class, I did not read Catcher in the Rye and it was hard for me to persuade someone to read the book, since I never have.
I agree... I don't think I've really thought much about censorship until now, other than to think that things are censored for really ridiculous reasons.
ReplyDeleteFirst off, that picture of the baby is cracking me up / creeping me out at the same time.
ReplyDeleteBut, it is so true that half of the things that are censored for public school aren't for good reason! Sometimes the schools don't even know why they're censoring things. I feel like censorship turns into a bandwagon in itself, but it takes away so many great opportunities to challenge our students and make them think.